Whitefish Bay

5235 N Bay Ridge Ave

Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

New-construction Colonial on an established east-side block

Built in 2025 on the lot of a tired 1950s house, this new Colonial is scaled to fit between its 1930s Colonial and Tudor neighbors, with lap siding, black shutters, and a covered front entry, while offering a thoroughly current plan. An open kitchen, dining, and family room spans the back of the house with a wall of doors to the yard; a front study has built-ins and a gas fireplace. Upstairs are four bedrooms and a laundry room, and the lower level is roughed in for a fifth bedroom and bath. Walk to Cumberland School and the Silver Spring shops.

Highlights

• New construction · builder warranty
• Energy Star envelope & tankless water heater
• Walk-in pantry & mudroom lockers
• Lower level roughed in for 5th bedroom
• Attached 2-car garage from the alley
• Whitefish Bay School District

Property facts

Property type

Single Family

Status

New

Year built

2025

Lot size

0.17 acres

Garage

2-car

Price / sq ft

$408

Annual taxes

New construction

HOA

None

Days on market

5

MLS #

1906102

Location

Payment calculator

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. MLS #1906102. Mock IDX demonstration data — not an active listing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Square footage and room dimensions are approximate.